Topics

Knowledge Creation Laboratory by CRM(xRM)

What happened to a company that continuously used Emotional Temperature for a year — The compounding effect of CRM 4.0

Hello, this is Matsubara, CRM Evangelist.

In the world of investing, there's a concept called "the power of compound interest." Interest is earned on the principal, and that interest earns interest again. Even a small difference at first grows exponentially over time.

The same thing happens with emotional temperature.

"One update today" is a small act. After meeting with a customer, you update their emotional state in 30 seconds. That's all. But when you add that up over a year, it becomes a "history of the customer's emotions," an asset that other companies can never imitate.

This article outlines, in chronological order, what actually happened to a company that continuously used EMOROCO CRM Lite to track emotional temperature for one year. Please note that this case study is a hypothetical story based on industry realities and the implementation patterns of multiple companies.


Why does emotional temperature have a compounding effect?

First, let's clarify why compound interest occurs.

The emotional temperature field records the customer's state at a specific moment. However, if you continue this for a year, you'll start to see patterns in their state of change. This is the essence of compound interest.

Initial data is limited (1-3 months): All we know right now is that "this customer is cool."

Stages in which data has been accumulated (6 months to 1 year): We can see a pattern: "This customer cools down in March every year and warms up again in April."

What changes when you can see the pattern? This allows for proactive actions, such as taking a preemptive stance in February before March arrives.

In other words, the value of emotional temperature starts with "knowing your current position" and evolves to "predicting the future." This evolution is the essence of the compounding effect.

There is yet another compounding effect. The accumulation of emotional temperatureAI learning data will be important.
EMOROCO CRM Lite is designed to improve accuracy the more you use it. Every line of data you enter today will determine the accuracy of your customer analysis a year from now.


Month 1 – "Unseen problems" become quantifiable.

The first thing that happens when you use emotional temperature is not "improvement," but "discovery."

The shock of setting the emotional temperature of all customers to the initial setting

Many companies set an emotional temperature for all customers on the first day of implementation. The moment this task is completed, almost everyone says the same thing.

"I didn't realize there were so many 'cool' and 'cold' words."

While it varies by industry, in many cases, the percentage of customers who start with a setting of "Cool" or lower is as high as 40-60%.

  • Insurance agency (180 clients): 43% are below cool.
  • Apparel select shop (100 customers): 57% preferred cool or below.
  • Tax accounting firm (43 client companies): 12 companies (28%) were below the "Cool" level.

It's not that I thought there were no problems; it's just that I couldn't see the problems. The moment I set the emotional temperature, the problems that were previously invisible became quantifiable.

The only thing you need to do in the first month is "discovery."

In the first month, you don't need to try to improve the emotional temperature. Simply discovering "where all customers currently stand" is enough.

This discovery will change my actions over the next six months.


Month 3 – The "proactive approach" begins.

If you continuously update your emotional temperature, proactive actions will automatically begin to emerge after three months.

The workflow starts to work.

In a company that has set up a workflow where "if emotional temperature drops below cool, automatically generate a follow-up task within 7 days," the following changes occur after 3 months.

before: Follow up only after you "vaguely sense" that a customer is about to leave. Three months later: The moment the sense of presence is converted into numbers, tasks automatically arrive.

This marks the beginning of a shift from sales based on intuition and gut feelings to a more strategic approach where action is taken based on data.

Overcoming the "Everyone Warm Problem"

A common problem many companies face in their third month is that "everyone has become too relaxed."

This pattern involves users continuously assigning "warm" to everyone due to psychological barriers such as feeling awkward about writing "cool" or fearing it might be used for evaluation. This is data degradation.

There are two ways to deal with this.

① Clearly define the criteria for judgment: The team needs to articulate specific behavioral criteria for each of the following categories: "hot," "warm," "cool," and "cold," and reach an agreement on them.

Hot: "Contacting them now would likely lead to a business deal." Warm: "The relationship is being maintained through regular contact." Cool: "More than 30 days have passed since the last contact, or their response has become less enthusiastic." Cold: "They are unreachable or clearly not interested."

② Clearly state that "emotional temperature will not be used as an evaluation metric": Managers must clearly state that emotional temperature is a "sensor of the customer's state," not a criterion for evaluating the employee. Unless this is stated, the data will not be accurate.


Month 6 – The "pattern" begins to emerge.

Once six months of data have been collected, the scattered data points begin to connect to form a line. Individual customer "emotional shift patterns" start to emerge.

"Seasonal emotional patterns" that appear by industry

Continued use will reveal industry-specific emotional temperature patterns.

Construction companies and renovation businesses: A pattern emerges where customers show little interest (cool) for the first two to three years after construction, but become more interested (warm) around five to seven years later as they start to notice deterioration of the exterior walls and equipment. By providing follow-up support at the six-and-a-half-year mark, before reaching the seventh year, it's possible to prevent them from switching to competitors.

Insurance agent: A pattern emerges: "Many customers experience a surge in emotional intensity during March-April (the start of the new fiscal year) and September-October (before their children start school) each year." This leads to an evolution in the strategy of concentrating approaches two months prior to these periods.

Professional services (tax accountant, social insurance and labor consultant): A pattern emerges: "Clients who tend to become less engaged three months before the end of the fiscal year are a sign that they are not receiving enough information." By increasing proactive information provision during the same period, client satisfaction improves.

The "seeds of referrals" appear in the sixth month.

We can also see a pattern where referrals are more likely to come from customers who have maintained a "hot" emotional state for two or more consecutive periods.

When analyzing the "referral source field" in combination with emotional temperature, data shows that "the referral rate of customers who remained in a 'hot' state for more than three months is 3 to 5 times higher than that of customers who were in a 'warm' state or lower."

Once this becomes clear, we add a workflow to initiate the conversation about referrals with customers who are still actively using our services. The design evolves.


Month 9 – A change in the person in charge makes a difference.

The value of continuously managing emotional temperature becomes most clearly apparent when there is a change in personnel.

It's not a matter of "transferring from 30 minutes to 5 minutes." It's about "transferring the entire story."

Traditional handovers involved simply transferring customer information, past contracts, and contact details. Having a continuous record of emotional connection fundamentally changes the quality of the handover.

The first thing a new person in charge will see is the "emotional temperature change graph."

"This customer was cold six months ago, but has been warm again for the past three months. Their emotional temperature rose when they discussed [topic] during their last contact (from narrative memo)."

With this information, the new representative can understand "what state this customer is currently in" from the very first contact and communicate accordingly.

No emotional temperature record: The new person in charge starts by resetting the relationship with a "let me introduce myself again." Emotional temperature recorded: The new person in charge will start the story by saying, "I've heard about XX from my predecessor."

From the customer's perspective, it becomes a company where the relationship continues even if the person in charge changes. This is called "the transfer of relationship assets."

Changes in retention rates after a change in personnel

When comparing a change of personnel with the transfer of emotional temperature records to a change of personnel without records:

  No record Emotional temperature is continuously recorded.
Retention rate after 3 months following a change in assigned personnel 71 % 94 %
The time it takes to repair a relationship after initial contact. Average 3-4 months Average 2-3 weeks
Customers have expressed disappointment that their assigned representative has changed. Many Almost none

Year 1 – The "organizational emotion sensor" is completed.

Beyond one year of continuous use, emotional temperature transforms from a "personal record" into "organizational knowledge."

You can manage your "customer portfolio" with one year's worth of data.

By looking at a year's worth of emotional temperature data, you can manage all your customers into four segments.

Segment A (Royalty): Customers who have maintained a "hot" to "warm" level of engagement for one year. They have the highest LTV and are the primary source of referrals. Strategy: Deepen relationships through special treatment.

Segment B (Recoverable Layer): This customer has been inactive for over six months, but has a history of being very active. A strategy that replicates "what worked back then" by reviewing their narrative notes would be effective.

Segment C (Aggression Risk Group): More than three months have passed since the cold spell. Instead of giving up, we will continue with "pressure-free contact" (such as sharing industry information) once or twice a year.

Segment D (Dormant Layer): No contact for over a year. This will be recorded as data, and the possibility of re-approaching will remain in mind when market changes occur.

This segment management shifts sales from the inefficient approach of "chasing every customer" to a strategic approach of "focusing on high-value segments."

Numbers that will appear one year from now

When analyzing implementation patterns across multiple industries and scales, a common change emerges after one year.

Changes in order rate and retention rate:

index Before implementation One year later
Customer retention rate Average 83% Average 91-95%
Number of customer referrals Base line 1.8 to 3 times
Retention rate after change of person in charge 71 % 94 %
Order rate for "emotionally charged hot customers" incomprehensible Measurable and improveable

Changes in time efficiency:

work Before implementation One year later
The time it takes to decide "who to contact today" 15-30 minutes/day 30 seconds (just look at the dashboard)
Handover time when the person in charge changes 2 to 4 hours 15-30 minutes
Monthly customer status report creation 2 to 3 hours 5 minutes (automatic calculation)

Three investment principles to maximize the power of compound interest

When analyzing the differences between companies that were able to continue for a year and those that became mere formalities along the way, we found that the successful companies shared three common operational principles.

Principle ①: The habit of "updating on the same day after contact"

Emotional temperature is "dead unless it's updated." Updating the emotional temperature of last week's contact today will reduce its accuracy. Only companies that make it a habit to update the data "within 30 seconds of contact with a customer" will maintain its freshness.

Principle ②: Monthly "CRM Doctor Health Checkup"

Once a month, we will have a 15-minute review session where you will answer the following questions.

  • Did the number of people below "Cool" increase or decrease compared to the previous month?
  • Of your hot customers, what percentage were you able to follow up with this month?
  • Are there any staff members who haven't updated their emotional temperature?

Without these monthly checkups, the data will gradually deteriorate.

Principle 3: Continue to adhere to the principle of "not using emotional temperature in evaluations."

The most common mistake in continuous operation over a year is the management error of "lowering the evaluation because there were too many cases of 'cool' or below." Emotional temperature is a "sensor of the customer's state," not a "criterion for evaluating the person in charge." Only organizations that adhere to this principle for a year will maintain the accuracy of their data.


Summary — "The organization one year from now" is created by "one update today".

The compounding effect of emotional temperature can be summarized in one sentence: "30 seconds today can change an organization a year from now."

Whether an organization becomes one year from now that "understands customers' emotional patterns," "maintains relationships even when the person in charge changes," and "generates referrals through its system" depends on whether you start updating your emotional temperature starting today.

The "co-creation with customers" aspect of CRM 4.0 cannot be achieved in a single day. Recording the emotional shifts with each interaction, and accumulating these records, creates the "customer's story." This timeframe is an asset that competitors can never replicate.

The first month begins with the shock of realizing that "most people are below cool." But a year later, that shock transforms into an asset: the organization's emotional sensor.

[The first step you can take starting today] First, open your customer list and evaluate each customer's current status on a four-point scale: Hot, Warm, Cool, or Cold. The moment you've set this for all your customers, previously unseen problems will become quantifiable.

You can try it with a 30-day free trial.
Digitalization and AI Implementation Subsidy 2026 Compatible Tool Number: DL07-0022934
Product Info:https://www.emoroco.com/


Related article

Person who wrote this article
Shinsuke Matsubara

Arcus Japan Representative Director / CRM Consultant
Click here for detailed profile
He has worked as a system engineer, architect, and consultant at Accenture and other companies, an evangelist at Infragistics (Microsoft MVP for Dynamics CRM (now Microsoft MVP for Business Solutions)), and a solutions specialist at Microsoft (in charge of Dynamics CRM products).He currently leads a service team specializing in CRM, supporting CRM implementation and business launches for companies of all sizes.At the same time, he works as a CRM evangelist, spreading the idea of "true" CRM through events and article contributions.
Having learned CRM at Accenture, and having advocated and globally popularized CRM 2.0 (platform-based CRM) at Microsoft, he is a legitimate successor to CRM and the longest-serving active CRM expert (CRM consultant/CRM doctor), having received an award at Worldwide.
Since then, as a leading expert in CRM who advocates CRM 3.0 (Personalized CRM) and CRM 4.0 (Creative CRM), he has been interviewed and received numerous awards both domestically and internationally from publications such as The Wall Street Journal, Newsweek, TIME, WORLDCOM, Mainichi Shimbun (Weekly Economist), and Nippon Cultural Broadcasting. He has also been selected as a representative company of the Kansai business community by "Keizaikai" for four consecutive years.
book:Versatylist - How to become a "1 in 1" talent by age 35

Interview article
For requests for interviews, lectures, etc., please contact us using the contact information below.
TEL +06-6195-7501-XNUMX
Inquiry via form

Articles in the same category